CHARLESTON, W.Va. – The Monongahela Power Company is asking ratepayers to pay more to bail out a Marion County power plant that critics charge is dirty, already expensive and damaging to the air, land and water.

Customers currently pay a bit above the market rate for the Grant Town Power Plant because the small power station was designed to burn waste coal – low-energy gob from old mines.

But Jim Kotcon, chair of the West Virginia chapter of the Sierra Club, says Monongahela Power is asking the Public Service Commission to make ratepayers pay even more to keep an especially dirty power plant running, and keep its operators out of bankruptcy.

"Mon Power really doesn't need that generation, and they certainly shouldn't have to force their customers to pay higher rates in order to keep that plant on-line," he states.

Monongahela Power argues that it does need the generating capacity and that Grant Town is helping to clean up an environmental issue.

Kotcon argues the environmental benefit is "marginal at best," and Grant Town is one of most expensive and polluting power sources in West Virginia.

Kotcon says if the PSC agrees to another in what is becoming a series of the coal plant bailouts, ratepayers would pay about twice the rate that wholesale electricity could be bought for off the grid. In return, he says they sustain a power plant that has some of the highest air pollution numbers in the West Virginia.

"Some of these gob piles are getting cleaned up, but at the same time they're creating new mines that require reclamation,” he stresses. “In addition the ash leads to leaching of salts and heavy metals and other problems going into the water."

The fly ash from Grant Town is being applied to mine remediation sites to reduce acid mine drainage.

But Kotcon points out the ash from gob is high in heavy metals, which are free to leach into the surface water from the old mines. He says there are cheaper, cleaner options that are less of a risk than the already subsidized Grant Town plant.

"Even at that inflated price, they are on the verge of bankruptcy,” Kotcon points out. “It is certainly not one that is competitive, given how cheap natural gas or wind power or even solar power would be."

Grant Town supporters say closing the power plant would be hard on the community and the 170 employees. The proposal would raise the cost of power from the plant by 14 percent.



get more stories like this via email

In last week's election, South Dakota voters defeated the carbon pipeline law by a wide margin, but pipeline companies could still gain ground in neighboring states. Nearly 60% of South Dakota voters said "no" to Referred Law 21, which would have imposed regulations to linear transmission facilities that favored industry over landowners. The law was largely driven by Summit Carbon Solutions' proposed 2,500 mile pipeline that would run through five states and store carbon underground in North Dakota.

Landowner advocate Ed Fischbach noted at a press event that the win was impressive considering that ethanol producers backed the law with nearly $3-million of campaign support.

"I think we won 65 of the 66 counties. And even though we were outspent about 50-to-1, we're very happy that we have prevailed on this. But we know the fight's not over," he said.

According to reporting from the North Dakota Monitor, Iowa has already granted Summit a permit. In Minnesota, where the company can't use eminent domain to get through certain properties, the state's Public Utilities Commission is expected to vote next month on a short segment of the pipeline.

Summit has said it will reapply for a permit through the South Dakota Public Utilities Commission next week after being denied one last year. But Chase Jensen of Dakota Rural Action said on the press call that this is the eighth consecutive month Summit has said it will reapply.

State Sen.-elect Joy Hohn, R-Hartford, who said she's excited to work on "eminent domain reform" at the Statehouse, was also on the call.

"We really have had a grassroots movement across South Dakota with a lot of new conservative legislators, and I am hopeful and think that we will bring forth a lot of good legislation that will protect our private property rights and keep our freedoms intact where they should be," she explained.

Hohn said pipeline rules are also expected from the Department of Transportation and the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration.


get more stories like this via email

President-elect Donald Trump's agenda for "energy dominance" could majorly impact leaders in the sector, including the state of Wyoming and the Tribes there. But some say the industry might have limited tolerance for blanket policy shifts. Before the election, the University of Wyoming hosted this year's Tribal Energy Summit, where major themes were carbon capture, rare earth elements and critical minerals and community engagement. After the election, there are questions about how far Trump will sidestep the nation's momentum toward renewable energy.

Daniel Cardenas, CEO of the National Tribal Energy Association and co-founder with the National Tribal Energy Association, expects the next Trump administration to look similar to the last one.

"They weren't outright anti-renewable. They were just preaching an "all-above" strategy, with more of a focus on fossil energy. But I think that's probably the route that things will go, which supports what Wyoming's already doing during Governor Gordon's administration is "all- the-above," he said.

Cardenas added despite campaign rhetoric, industry leaders see opportunities in a varied approach to energy production. Exxon Mobil's CEO this week urged Trump to stay in the Paris climate agreement, which Trump promised to back out of in 2017.

A vast majority of the U.S. reserves of key energy-transition metals are located within 35 miles of Native American reservations, according to the investment firm MSCI. Cardenas says tribes have been left out of the conversation on the energy transition-which he calls the "energy evolution"- but that they could be key partners.

"Collectively, tribes are the largest private landowners in the United States outside the federal government. So no matter what, if the country needs and wants to develop more infrastructure, the path to that is through Indian Country," Cardenas added.

Investments in clean energy-especially in red states like Wyoming-are foundational to President Biden's 2022 Inflation Reduction Act, which Trump has called a "green new scam." Trump's power to change Biden's law, however, may be limited by Congress.


get more stories like this via email

An electric cooperative supplying power to Western Colorado is pioneering energy independence for homes, businesses and farms.

They are creating a virtual power plant, a network connecting residential rooftop solar and battery storage to smart appliances such as heat pumps, electric vehicles and water heaters.

Lisa Reed, energy programs manager for Holy Cross Energy, said the microgrid can be tapped to keep the lights on when power lines from coal and gas fired plants are disrupted.

"Holy Cross Energy is implementing the use of virtual power plants to help with resilience, both for large events such as wildfires, but also smaller events, to keep our power reliable," Reed explained.

Holy Cross is standing up virtual power plants by providing affordable home battery storage options to members who subscribe to their Power+ program. The batteries store energy when demand is low and supply power during peak times or outages. Virtual power plants also reduce reliance on costly, polluting energy from coal and gas-fired units.

Tyler McDermott, regional organizer for the Western Colorado Alliance, said virtual power plants are also important for national security. If a hacker wants to take out a power grid, they can target a single conventional power plant but it is much harder to knock out a decentralized grid extending across entire communities. Microgrids also cost ratepayers 40% to 60% less than building coal or gas powered plants.

"We all want to pay less for our energy, we all want our lights to turn on when we flip the switch, we want our ACs to work in the hot summers," McDermott outlined. "Virtual power plants are the answer to one of the biggest problems that we're facing all across the nation but especially in rural communities."

Reed noted networked residential and business batteries also help community members save money on their electric bills in the middle of the day, when energy from conventional power plants is the most expensive.

"Holy Cross Energy discharges those batteries onto the grid to reduce our peak load, thus saving money for our members in power supply costs," Reed added.


get more stories like this via email