skip to main content
skip to newscasts

Friday, April 4, 2025

Public News Service Logo
facebook instagram linkedin reddit youtube twitter
view newscast page
play newscast audioPlay

'Fair likelihood' Trump administration violated court order, judge says; ME federal workers rally against Trump order to end labor protections; VA military members face outsized impacts as consumer watchdog agency dismantled; OH environmental group fears federal cuts will hurt job opportunities.

view newscast page
play newscast audioPlay

The administration stands behind its tariffs, despite declines in markets. Advocates nationwide push back against federal rollbacks affecting military families, and the environment and big budget plans advance in Congress.

view newscast page
play newscast audioPlay

The proposed dismantling of the Depart. of Education has rural schools scared, postal carriers say USPS changes will hurt rural communities most, fiber networks to improve internet may be supplanted by Musk's satellites, and it's time to PLAY BALL!

Civil-Rights Watchdogs Question Necessity of Marcy’s Law

play audio
Play

Friday, June 21, 2019   

HARRISBURG, Pa. – An amendment to the state Constitution promoted as enshrining the rights of crime victims may be on the Pennsylvania ballot in November, but opponents fear it could do more harm than good.

Marcy's Law passed in the Senate for the second time on Wednesday, but must be approved by voters in the General Election before it can go into effect. Supporters say the amendment would give crime victims rights equal to those of the accused – like a right to restitution, to be advised of all developments, and a right to refuse depositions and discovery requests.

But according to Elizabeth Randol, legislative director at the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania, the law gives alleged victims a role in criminal proceedings before there's been a determination of guilt.

"By inserting them into the process and giving them constitutional rights, it would run headfirst into the presumption of innocence that the framers were insistent was in place before the state was able to incarcerate – if not execute – someone," says Randol.

She notes that Marcy's Law doesn't bring any additional resources for victims' services and has no provisions to guarantee that it is enforced.

Randol points out that South Dakota passed a version of Marcy's Law that, like the Pennsylvania law, states that every victim of even the most petty crime is entitled to the notification provisions of the law.

"All their agencies were doing was spending time on notifications and couldn't do any of the other work that they were trying to get done on behalf of victims," says Randol. “So, they had to go back and re-amend their constitution and make those notifications an opt-in."

She adds that under current Pennsylvania law, people can register as crime victims and select the kinds of notifications they want to receive.

Now that Marcy's Law has cleared the General Assembly, the state needs to publicize the proposed amendment and decide on the exact language voters will see on the ballot. Randol notes this process also can be difficult.

"Kentucky just permanently blocked implementation of Marcy's law because the ballot language was so vague, it did not properly communicate to voters what exactly it did and the amount of money that it was going to cost," says Randol.

She believes Marcy's Law would do little actual good for Pennsylvania crime victims, while putting long-recognized rights of the accused in serious jeopardy.

Disclosure: ACLU of Pennsylvania contributes to our fund for reporting on Civil Rights, Human Rights/Racial Justice, Immigrant Issues, LGBTQIA Issues. If you would like to help support news in the public interest, click here.


get more stories like this via email
more stories
In addition to gut health benefits, many researchers say reducing meat consumption and increasing plant-based foods can help lower greenhouse gas emissions, conserve water and reduce the environmental footprint of food production. (NDABCREATIVITY/Adobe Stock)

Health and Wellness

play sound

By Dawn Attride for Sentient.Broadcast version by Chrystal Blair for Michigan News Connection reporting for the Sentient-Public News Service Collabora…


Social Issues

play sound

Nearly 22,000 Florida college students could lose critical tuition help under a state House budget proposal. The plan would cut $3,500 annual grants …

Environment

play sound

Minnesota bird enthusiasts should keep their binoculars handy. April is a good month to spot various species migrating back to the region. Experts …


The U.S. Senate voted 52-48 to end the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's overdraft-fee protection regulation. (Adobe Stock)

play sound

As President Donald Trump dismantles the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, advocates of the agency warn that veterans and military service …

Social Issues

play sound

Arizona lawmakers are considering a bill to prevent cryptocurrency scams and regulate what are known as "crypto kiosks." Brendon Blake, AARP …

Environment

play sound

A huge offshore wind project is forging ahead off Humboldt Bay in Northern California - and Saturday, elected officials will tour the deepwater port …

Social Issues

play sound

Some Colorado lawmakers are scrambling to protect voter rights after President Donald Trump issued an executive order to require proof of citizenship …

 

Phone: 303.448.9105 Toll Free: 888.891.9416 Fax: 208.247.1830 Your trusted member- and audience-supported news source since 1996 Copyright © 2021