Issue 1 Puts Public Safety, Bail Before Ohio Voters
Tuesday, November 8, 2022
Supporters of a proposed constitutional amendment are putting public safety on Ohio's ballot this Election Day. Issue 1 came about after the Ohio Supreme Court ruled in January that a $1.5-million bond set for a murder suspect was excessive and unconstitutional.
If passed, Issue 1 would require judges to use public safety factors when setting bail, including the seriousness of the crime or a defendant's criminal history. Supporters, including the governor and attorney general, claim it will give judges the tools they need to keep violent offenders off the streets.
Jeremy Cherson, senior policy advisor with The Bail Project, countered judges already consider public safety.
"When they do consider public safety, though, they can preventively detain people," Cherson said. "There are some limitations and challenges with that as it currently is, but this constitutional amendment doesn't remedy those problems."
Issue 1 would also remove the Ohio Supreme Court's authority in reviewing factors for setting bail, and allow state lawmakers to decide instead.
Emily Cole, director of Ohio Families Unite for Political Action and Change, argued that Issue 1 is problematic because it enshrines cash bail into the state constitution, making it more difficult to make changes in the future.
She added it also reinforces an unfair system that allows wealthier defendants to essentially purchase their freedom.
"Public safety is 100% being used as a dog whistle in this ballot language where it's supposed to instill a certain reaction from voters at the ballot box," Cole said. "And this is an attempt to demonize Black, Brown and lower-income communities."
Cole added Issue 1 does nothing to address crime, which in her opinion is a failure of society.
"That is a lack of resources in a community and a lack of investment led to the circumstances that led to that instance," she said. "Anyone who wants to actually work on public safety and reducing crime should be working on fully funding our communities."
Ohio voters today (11/8) will decide whether or not to pass Issue 1, which would require courts to use public safety factors when setting bail amounts and conditions. It also would eliminate the Ohio Supreme Court's authority in setting procedures around bail and giving the power to the Legislature. Comments from Jeremy Cherson, senior policy advisor, The Bail Project; and Emily Cole, director, Ohio Families Unite for Political Action and Change.
Opponents note that Issue One also disrupts the work on two bipartisan reform bills, HB 315 and SB 182 that would end cash bail and base decisions on an individual's circumstances.
get more stories like this via email
Congress has signed off on a bill that preserves federal protections for same-sex and interracial marriages. A legal expert in Wisconsin says it …
Airport service workers rallied in Washington, D.C., Thursday to demand Congress pass legislation ensuring they receive a livable wage with stronger …
Before the pandemic, one in five people in Los Angeles County lacked consistent access to food - and in 2021, one in four low-income families …
Electric vehicles are an environmentally friendly way to get from one place to another, but the lack of charging stations often limits drivers to …
As Americans make end-of-year donations to their favorite causes, those that help children with cancer and their families say these households need …
A labor union representing agricultural workers in Ohio, North Carolina and Virginia says it isn't waiting around for federal immigration reform to …
As the year comes to a close, the Sierra Club of Connecticut is looking back on some of its accomplishments and challenges. The group focuses on …
Tribal leaders from the Northwestern U.S. have been in Washington, D.C., this week to discuss how waste from mines in British Columbia is threatening …