A recent report looking at executive compensation found companies with the most overpaid CEOs had lower returns to shareholders than the S&P average.

The nonprofit shareholder advocacy group As You Sow recently produced its 10th report on the 100 most overpaid CEOs. The report found while the average S&P 500 firm saw annualized returns of 8.5%, companies on the most overpaid list lagged at 7.9 % with the 25 worst seeing only a 6% return.

Rosanna Landis Weaver, director of wage justice and executive pay for As You Sow, said over time, changes in social norms, corporate compensation strategies, the tax code and rules around stock repurchases have contributed to overpaid executives.

"If we look at the period of history when America was a leader in creating solid middle class jobs, but also industry growth, companies plowed back any excess money into the company, into research and development into new initiatives," Weaver pointed out. "What we've had companies saying lately is, 'You know what the best thing I can do with this money is buy my own stock.'"

Since passage of the Dodd Frank bill, shareholders can vote on executive compensation. Weaver pointed out when shareholders vote against excessive CEO pay, corporate boards listen and many have made changes with some reducing executive pay.

In the 1960s, executive pay averaged about 20 times more than their employees. Current data show the number now averages 300 times more, and the report showed the most overpaid executives make thousands of times more than their average worker. Weaver argued no one person added that much value to a company.

"There is no person in the world that added as much value as 1,000 other people," Weaver contended. "There's no question if 1,000 workers disappeared, versus if the CEO disappeared, what would be the outcome."

When As You Sow began its reports 10 years ago, the average compensation of the 10 most overpaid
CEOs was $56 million. This time, the number was $88 million, a 59% increase. While boards have long been compensating executives with stock options, Weaver noted it creates the potential for short term thinking.

"If you attract somebody who's primary interest is seeing how much they can score, that's not good for shareholders long term, because that incentivizes a real short-term focus," asserted. "Maybe you want to cut jobs and cut services, and Wall Street likes that, and the stock price goes up, but you're hollowing out a company in the long term. And I think we've seen too much of that."

She added some shareholder groups are now advocating for changing stock ownership rules for executives so they are required to hold shares for a longer period of time after leaving the company.

This story was produced based on original reporting by Sonali Kolhatkar for Yes! Magazine.


get more stories like this via email

Today is National Postal Workers Day, a celebration of the job they do to deliver the mail.

Postal workers provide a vital service, especially during big election years like 2024 and in states like Oregon where elections are conducted completely by mail.

Daniel Cortez, Oregon legislative and political director for the American Postal Workers Union, noted the critical role his colleagues play.

"Whether it be America's election mail or letters from grandparents, care packages to our service members overseas, vital prescriptions for our seniors and veterans," Cortez outlined. "It's important to remember that all of that happens because of the dedication of the postal workers day in and day out."

The United States Postal Service was established by Benjamin Franklin on July 26, 1775.

The Postal Service is currently experiencing a shake-up. Trump-appointed Postmaster General Louis DeJoy is implementing his 10-year Delivering For America plan to modernize the Postal Service's network. It is meant job eliminations and sorting center cuts Cortez argued have hurt mail delivery. For instance, he pointed out sorting in Oregon has been consolidated to one center in Portland.

"It's imperative that the American people know that this slowdown is manufactured by the Postal Service," Cortez contended. "Everything from failure to properly staff offices to just deliberately slowing down how fast mail moves."

DeJoy has remained in office under President Joe Biden because only the Postal Board of Governors can oust him. Biden has delayed nominations for the board, delaying any potential change in leadership at the Postal Service.

With the July 4 holiday approaching, families are likely to spend time at municipal parks to celebrate and Parks Department staff in Minneapolis hope their labor dispute sheds light on the increasing demands in their line of work.

This week, Minneapolis Parks and Recreation Board workers held an informational picket as they seek better pay and safer working conditions. They have also authorized a potential strike in the coming days.

Mitchell Clendenan, service area crew leader for the Minneapolis Parks and Recreation Board, said they feel their requests are being ignored, while at the same time, his colleagues are asked to do more with not enough support.

"In our heyday, we had upwards of 160 park keepers and that was probably in the 1980s," Clendenan noted. "Today, we only have 114 but the amount of land and parks that keep getting built keeps going up."

The union representing workers, Laborers' International Union of North America Local 363, compiled data it said underscored park keepers in Minneapolis are underpaid compared to surrounding communities. Organizers said there is a gap of more than $7 an hour. Officials on the management side have consistently stated they are bargaining in good faith.

As for other job challenges, Clendenan emphasized workers often start their days before the sun comes up, cleaning buildings and pools and disposing of needles and human waste.

"We have to deal with the unhoused," Clendenan observed. "It's just a lot of different pressures that society kind of, just; I don't think they understand the full extent of it."

He also pointed out one of their arborists was recently shocked by a power line, requiring a hospital visit. Other crew members say arborists have to earn prestigious certifications but struggle to cover living expenses based on their pay.

The demands come as Minneapolis consistently lands near the top of national rankings for best park systems in the country.

Depending on who you ask, the economy is on a solid path to improvement or is a drag on working families.

A Wisconsin educator said he is seeing positive economic trends and he credits federal policy.

John Havlicek has been teaching in La Crosse for a quarter-century and pointed out it once was a destination district. But he feels no public school system has the distinction anymore, as administrators scramble to attract teachers.

Havlicek, also a union leader, noted he has seen how the Biden administration's efforts on student loan forgiveness are having a positive impact on his colleagues. One way is through homeownership, which he acknowledged is out of reach for many in the field.

"That is not conducive to getting the best and the brightest into our classrooms," Havlicek argued. "The student loan forgiveness then is a huge deal because that two, three, four, five hundred dollars a month would be freed up for folks to spend elsewhere on something like a house."

He wants policymakers to get even more creative, suggesting a federal match to get states to boost education spending. Havlicek pointed out new federal investments in infrastructure and clean energy have helped local universities and hospitals expand. Critics of the moves said they helped fuel recent bouts of inflation.

Havlicek emphasized jobs tied to public works projects in his area are strengthening public unions, after Wisconsin Republicans have tried to weaken them in recent decades. It includes the repeal of state prevailing-wage laws. He stressed workers now are benefiting from labor standards and training included in policies like the Inflation Reduction Act.

"These are high-paying jobs and when we couple that with the (local) technical college, these folks can get their training, and they can raise families, they, you know, buy their groceries, they go out for dinner," Havlicek outlined.

Immigration is a thorny topic on the campaign trail but Havlicek underscored it is important to have new career pathways as La Crosse's population becomes more diverse. La Crosse has seen a nearly 70% increase in Latino residents since 2010.


get more stories like this via email