For many in Nebraska's child-care industry, which was struggling even before the pandemic, the "Child Care Stabilization" funds in the American Rescue Plan Act made a huge difference. The money must be disbursed by Sept. 30, causing concern about a "funding cliff" for child care.

Catherine Huddleston-Casas, Ph.D., associate director of workforce planning and development at the Buffett Early Childhood Institute at the University of Nebraska, said the pandemic shone a light on the "poverty wages" many child-care workers receive. She said some found they could make better money in less-demanding jobs.

"The knowledge and expertise that is developed through the process of working under a seasoned child-care provider - all of that is going to be lost if we don't do something to try to keep our providers in their positions," she said.

The Nebraska Department of Health and Human Services distributed the stabilization funds in a variety of ways, including stipends to employees at licensed child-care centers, and grants to center owners and staff to help pay down school loans. In a survey of Nebraska providers, 87% reported receiving some COVID relief money in the previous year, and most had used it for rent and utilities. Today, Nebraska has 10% fewer child-care programs than before the pandemic.

Grants also helped centers expand their capacity. Ninety-one-percent of Nebraska counties have a shortage of licensed child-care slots, and 11 counties have no licensed providers.

Susan Sarver, Ph.D., director of workforce planning and development at the Buffett Institute, said the way funds were disbursed may help the state experience a less severe "funding cliff" than it might have.

"Some states are still maintaining centers, so they're paying wages through those pandemic funds," she said, "and when that money disappears, those are the places that are going to have the biggest drop."

Sarver acknowledged that only when there's data to examine will it be possible to evaluate the sustainability of Nebraska's approach.

Huddleston-Casas authored a recent study showing the gap to fully fund Nebraska's early-childhood care and education grew from 51% in 2017 to 57% in 2021. She said there won't be any quick fixes, but examination of the current system is crucial, including the way it's funded. She considers this especially important because of what we've learned about child development.

"They're not just passive recipients; there's a lot going on in a baby's brain," she said. "But in what ways does the system we have give us the opportunity to do better? Or are we stuck with a system that doesn't know how to accommodate the developmental needs of children?"

New York families are still dealing with child care barriers despite improvements.

A new report found more than half the state is a child care desert with parents having to leave the workforce because they cannot access it.

While the Child Care Assistance Program has improved, it does not make up for other shortcomings.

Lara Kyriakou, associate director of early childhood policy and advocacy for Ed Trust-New York and the report's co-author, said one of the biggest barriers is lacking knowledge about available child care programs.

"Many families reported difficulties just learning about available programs including navigating application processes," Kyriakou observed. "A lot of families spoke about learning of programs from other parents or other key trusted relationships that they had in the community."

Other issues include restrictions due to a person's immigration status, or benefits cliffs where a family earns a little too much to qualify for programs. Some recommendations to fix the situation include further expanding New York's child tax credit and working families tax credit and investing in the child care workforce to hire new and retain existing workers.

Reports showed the state's child care industry workforce fell 32% from 2019 to 2023.

Enacting such changes could help New York State reach its goal of cutting child poverty in half by 2032. The report calls for a $1.2 billion sustaining investment in the child care industry.

Jenn O'Connor, director of partnerships and early childhood policy for Ed Trust-New York, said making it a sustaining investment would give child care workers a salary matching the cost of living.

"Child care providers who are predominantly women and predominantly women of color make less than your pizza delivery guy half the time," O'Connor emphasized. "They're providing an essential service and they're educating our youngest children."

The newly announced Invest in Our New York Act could pay for this. The package of bills would have corporations and New York's ultra-wealthy residents pay their fair share of taxes and the money would then be spent on child care, education and affordable housing.

Pandemic-era federal aid for early childhood educators expired last month and Wyoming lawmakers this year failed to pass a bill which could have helped. Some hope offering a higher degree could be an answer.

The 2024 Early Childhood Workforce Index shows the median wage for Wyoming early childhood educators in 2022 was $10.60 per hour, 28% lower than what is considered a living wage of $14.70.

Nikki Baldwin, director of the Wyoming Early Childhood Outreach Network at the University of Wyoming, said child care programs close regularly in the state.

"We hear about them almost weekly and it can be really devastating for Wyoming families," Baldwin observed.

The study's recommendations include increasing public funding for the early childhood education sector. The U.S. currently invests just $4,000 per child, per year, compared with $14,000 invested in other wealthy nations.

Baldwin pointed out the University of Wyoming is currently developing a bachelor's degree in early childhood education. In Wyoming, the owners and directors need a high school diploma. The new program will be offered in-person or fully remote, which could help more rural and isolated educators.

"They're so motivated to continue to learn," Baldwin emphasized. "Even though compensation isn't tied to their continued learning, they're still saying yes and trying to do more and trying to learn more and improve every day."

Baldwin hopes the new program will roll out in 2026.

Anna Powell, senior research and policy associate for the Berkeley Center for the Study of Childcare Employment at the University of California-Berkeley, noted pandemic-era federal aid through American Rescue Plan grants expired in September.

"That means that it's time for states and localities to really step up and think about how they're going to address the need to sustain early care and education workers going forward," Powell contended.

The Wyoming Joint Education Committee sponsored a bill last spring which would have allowed qualified families struggling with poverty to put state funds toward limited early education childhood expenses. Instead, the Wyoming Education Savings Accounts Act passed, which did not include child care or preschool.


get more stories like this via email

Idaho has suspended enrollment in a child-care benefits program, and families are expected to feel the squeeze.

The Department of Health and Welfare has temporarily paused enrollment in the Idaho Child Care Program, which provides assistance to low-income families. The income requirement for families to qualify is expected to drop from 175% of the federal poverty level to 130% when the pause is lifted.

Lori Fascilla, executive director of Giraffe Laugh Early Learning Centers, which serve people of all income levels with help from the Idaho Child Care Program, said it could be in jeopardy now.

"We're talking at least 30 kids that now we're looking at our situation going, 'How are we going to support these families until the pause is over, and will they even qualify once it is?'" Fascilla explained.

Families in a few situations will still be able to enroll in the Idaho Child Care Program, including those experiencing homelessness, caring for a foster child or caring for a child with a disability. The Department of Health and Welfare said it paused enrollment because the program is projected to go over its budget.

Fascilla noted child care is a struggle across the state, with hundreds of centers closing since the start of the pandemic.

"Part of that is there are zero state investments in children five and under in Idaho," Fascilla contended. "We're one of only three states that is still holding out on investing in early childhood or preschool programs, or anything like that."

Fascilla argued child care is crucial for ensuring parents can work and children are ready for school when they start kindergarten.


get more stories like this via email