Small businesses in Thomas and Davis say they would prefer a planned four-lane highway to be rerouted north, instead of running through what they say are environmentally valuable and outdoor recreation-based regions.

Pamela Moe, runs a consulting business in Tucker County which does environmental and educational work with nonprofits. She is also a member of the Tucker County Chamber of Commerce, which recently sent its members a survey seeking feedback on the impacts of Corridor H on small businesses. While the results haven't yet been publicly released, Moe said many owners are concerned about the effect of a highway on tourism in the neighboring towns.

"It's been interesting to watch what has happened to the economy of the county over time," Moe observed. "It has become primarily a tourism and outdoor recreation is the driver now, and both towns, the businesses have increased. It has become very much -- they have become very much -- destinations in and of themselves."

The Federal Highway Administration and West Virginia Division of Highways recently extended the public comment period to Nov. 3 for the section of Corridor H between Wardensville and the Virginia state line.

People can submit a comment online or by mail.

Comments for the Parsons-Davis section can also be submitted online. The comment period for Parsons-Davis ends on December 12.

The state contended the project will open up remote areas in Grant, Tucker and Hardy counties to economic development and boost travel between West Virginia, Virginia and Washington, D.C.

Moe countered the region's natural beauty, including multiple state parks, wilderness areas and public lands are at risk from development.

"The whole Tucker County, I think it's a crown jewel, and it also has challenging terrain, unstable geology," Moe asserted. "I think that the need to look at alternatives is critical. And right now, that doesn't seem to be something that is taking place."

Moe added local petitions have emerged calling for diverting the highway in various places to preserve wildlife habitat and waterways.

"There have been some petitions done locally," Moe pointed out. "In particular, targeting the businesses in both Thomas and Davis. And in both cases, the majority of businesses in both towns prefer the northern route."

So far, more than 2,200 residents have signed a petition calling for a better route.

Wisconsin's largest city has seen recent debate over highway expansion plans amid environmental concerns, and a new study suggested for similar projects, some effects could be limited if narrower traffic lanes are prioritized.

The expansion plan in Milwaukee involves a stretch of Interstate 94. Research from the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health was more focused on urban roadways with speed limits of around 35 miles an hour.

Shima Hamidi, director of the Center for Climate-Smart Transportation and assistant professor of public health at Johns Hopkins University who helped lead the study, said switching from lane widths between 11 and 12 feet, long the norm, down to 9 feet helps reduce traffic collisions. She pointed out it also leaves more room for options not involving vehicles.

"It will help many people to switch from driving to other modes of transportation, such as biking and walking," Hamidi explained. "Which could result in greenhouse gas emission reductions from transportation."

The study contended with narrower lanes, people will not feel compelled to drive as fast and will be more alert. Hamidi acknowledged while the approach might slow traffic, past research shows minimal effects, which means the changes would not cancel out environmental benefits. Other studies have shown expanding the number of lanes, in general, does not reduce congestion.

Hamidi also noted transportation planners and engineers have expressed liability concerns, but she emphasized her team's study is one of the first to give cities and states firm data, on the traffic safety side, showing skinnier lanes are more effective.

"We are getting more and more interest from transportation planners, mostly at the local level," Hamidi observed. "Cities are eager and interested to really see how this could be implemented."

Hamidi added the next steps involve more research to quantify some of the other impacts, including air pollution. The study issued this month analyzed nearly 1,200 streets in seven cities around the
U.S. The findings come amid a gradual increase in pedestrian fatalities over the past decade.


get more stories like this via email

A Connecticut Department of Transportation study has outlined plans to make Hartford a walkable city.

The Greater Hartford Mobility Study proposes projects to increase safety and reduce highway congestion in Connecticut's capital region.

One proposal in the study calls for burying portions of I-84 and I-91. Moving sections of the highways underground would call for the building of new bridges crossing the Connecticut River for people to use bikes or e-scooters.

Jay Stange, coordinator for Transport Hartford Academy, said despite the benefits of this study, there are some deficiencies.

"This project also continues to route very high volumes of interstate traffic right through the center of the neighborhoods in the north end of Hartford," Stange pointed out. "All of the air-quality impacts are going to continue with this project as it's conceptualized."

Data Haven's 2023 Community Well-Being Index found Hartford residents are almost 2.5 times more likely to go to the emergency room for asthma compared with residents of nearby towns.

Although a timeline for the projects is uncertain, there has been some opposition to the I-84 rerouting. Stange is confident as the project continues in the development phase, it will shift into a project all people can get behind.

As the project gets underway, there have been differences on how to approach it. One recommendation is a bottom-up approach, meaning slower work to remove I-84 on ramps, reconnecting the North End of the city, and implementation of bus rapid transit. Stange described the other approach being considered.

"On the other end, we have a top-down approach; a very large transformative approach that approaches the double-digit billion-dollar price tag," Stange observed.

He noted people are wary of how to proceed given large-scale projects from the 1960s had negative impacts on Hartford. Stange added people are looking to combine both approaches to get the best version of this project for the city.

New York advocates want to see changes made to MTA's 20-year needs assessment.

Along with infrastructure modernization work, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's assessment proposes making most New York City Subway and Long Island Railroad stations handicap accessible by 2045. However, policy experts feel it's missing certain elements.

Rachael Fauss, senior policy advisor for Reinvent Albany, said they need a cost estimate for bringing the entire New York Subway system up to a state of good repair.

"Without having an estimate of the cost, both in the short term, so over a five-year period, and then also a 20-year period, there's nothing to measure the forthcoming capital plan against," she said. "You can't know if the right investments are being made if you don't have a place to start from."

She added that previous needs assessments have included cost estimates, but the repair and service needs were highlighted more.

Along with Reinvent Albany, the Citizens Budget Commission is also calling for transparency in the price of the assessment and upcoming Capital Plan. While the assessment talks about such expansion projects as the Second Avenue Subway and the Interborough Express, Fauss said she feels full system repairs must be a priority.

She's also concerned about spending overruns on long-term projects that can develop even when costs are laid out in detail. The East Side Access project, bringing the Long Island Railroad to Grand Central Terminal, saw billions of dollars in cost overruns in 2018. But, Fauss noted that unforeseen circumstances make developing costs estimates harder.

"I think there is some understanding that inflation and factors the MTA can't control," she said, "supply limitations, vendors to do the job; there are things that are out of their control."

In spite of this, Fauss is insistent on at least having a cost estimate for the first five years of the capital plan and needs assessment. Although MTA has implemented cost estimates on projects that had significant cost overruns, she noted it can serve as a benchmark for progress.


get more stories like this via email